Tea party claims win over Stupak’s decision not to run again; he says he accomplished top goal
By John Flesher, APFriday, April 9, 2010
Stupak, linchpin of health bill, calls it quits
MARQUETTE, Mich. — Rep. Bart Stupak insists that tea party activists outraged over his crucial support of health care legislation didn’t run him out of office, but his decision to retire gives conservatives a rallying point as they target Democrats in the midterm elections.
The congressman, an anti-abortion Democrat whose high-profile role in the “Obamacare” debate earned him enemies on the left and the right, said Friday that he’s leaving because he’s tired and has accomplished his No. 1 goal: improving health care.
“The tea party did not run me out,” Stupak told The Associated Press in a phone interview. “If you know me and my personality, I would welcome the challenge.”
Stupak had been a consistent landslide winner in his sprawling northern Michigan district, and the opening now offers Republicans a ripe opportunity to regain a seat they held for decades until Stupak prevailed in 1992.
His political foes — tea party activists and abortion opponents — both claimed credit for forcing him into retirement, and Michigan GOP Chairman Ron Weiser declared that the nine-term incumbent had become the first casualty of the battle over health care in Congress.
“Bart Stupak’s decision to retire is emblematic of the many Democrats in swing districts who have been forced into casting tough votes in favor politically unpopular policies at the behest of House Speaker Nancy Pelosi,” added Ken Spain, communications director for the House Republican campaign committee.
No prominent or well-funded Republican, however, had stepped in to challenge Stupak, who said he was confident of winning re-election. The 58-year-old said he was withdrawing because he was worn out and wanted more family time after nearly 18 years in Congress and the grueling health care battle.
“I’ve struggled with this decision. I’ve wanted to leave a couple of times, but I always thought there was one more job to be done,” he said at a news conference.
“Since the day I took office, I fought to improve the quality and accessibility of health care,” he said. “My No. 1 legislative goal has been accomplished.”
Stupak had little national profile before the health care debate. He led a group of anti-abortion Democrats who held out against the legislation until President Barack Obama agreed to sign an executive order ensuring that federal funds would not be used for abortions. That quickly transformed him from the bane of the bill’s supporters to the bane of its foes.
As he announced his decision, Stupak mentioned threats he has received because of his stance on various issues, including health care.
“The three o’clock in the morning phone calls, that’s people outside the district,” he said. “That’s not my district. I know these folks. They wouldn’t do that. You sort of just ignore it and move on.”
Stupak’s retirement marked the latest in a series of political setbacks for a party striving to retain control of Congress against a backdrop of recession and high unemployment.
So far, 20 Democrats and 20 Republicans have either resigned or announced they will not run again in the fall, but the equal numbers mask a clear advantage for the GOP. Democrats will be defending at least a dozen potentially competitive open districts, while all but two of the Republican retirements are in generally safe GOP territory.
Democrats currently have a 253-177 majority, with five vacancies that will be filled by special elections before November. It takes 218 to win a majority.
There was no tangible evidence Stupak was in political jeopardy in his socially conservative district. His Democratic primary opponent supports abortion rights, and none of his three Republican challengers had reported any campaign cash on hand.
Democratic strategists said Stupak’s name had not appeared on any internal list of party incumbents who might be in jeopardy in the fall.
“Stupak has always had very high personal popularity,” said Bernie Porn, a pollster with Lansing-based EPIC-MRA. “I would have difficulty believing the tea party influence in and of itself would have driven him out.”
Stupak defeated former state Rep. Tom Casperson with 65 percent of the vote in 2008 while fellow Democrat Obama got 50 percent of the congressional district’s vote. Republican George W. Bush carried the district in 2004, while Stupak won re-election.
“People up here are very independent, and they vote that way,” said state Rep. Gary McDowell, a Democrat from Rudyard in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula. “There’s probably more ticketsplitters and more independent-thinking people in this district I would say than probably any other part of the state.”
With his retirement announcement, five Democratic state legislators — including Senate Democratic Leader Mike Prusi — say they may run for Stupak’s seat. Kevin Elsenheimer, the state House GOP leader, also is showing interest.
Tea party activists, laboring to establish themselves as a force in the 2010 campaign, were particularly vocal. In a written statement, the organization said more than 400 people turned out for a rally it held Wednesday night in Stupak’s district, and another, larger event was planned as part of a nationwide Tea Party Express tour.
The group announced a few days ago it would spend $250,000 on radio and television commercials seeking his defeat.
“Stupak was not longer able to hide his betrayal of conservative principles because the tea party movement was determined to educate the voters in his district of his vote of betrayal for Obamacare,” said Bryan Shroyer, the group’s political director.
Stupak unflinchingly stood up to the White House and the Democratic leadership last year when he helped assure that an early version of the health care bill included strong anti-abortion protections supported by conservative groups.
At the same time, he stressed he wanted to vote for health care legislation, and it was clear he hoped to do so in the run-up to the House’s key vote on the final version of the bill last month.
As part of the final compromise, Obama agreed to sign an executive order stipulating that no federal funds would be used to finance abortions as a result of passage of the health care legislation. The step secured the votes of Stupak and a handful of other Democratic opponents of abortion rights, but angered anti-abortion groups who said the order was not enough.
Associated Press Special Correspondent David Espo in Washington, D.C. and writers Mike Householder in Detroit and Tim Martin in Lansing contributed to this report.
Tags: Barack Obama, Government Regulations, Health Care Reform, Industry Regulation, Lansing, Marquette, Michigan, North America, Political Issues, United States, Voting Districts
