Abu Dhabi feeds Dubai $10 billion to cover debt on deadline, calming financial worries for now
By Adam Schreck, APMonday, December 14, 2009
Dubai’s $10B bailout by Abu Dhabi calms fears
DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — Oil-rich Abu Dhabi pumped $10 billion into its indebted neighbor Monday, sending stocks soaring while sparing Dubai and the rest of the Emirates federation the humiliation of an imminent default by one of the struggling Arab boomtown’s star companies.
The bailout was about more than petrodollar transfers from one United Arab Emirates sheikdom to the other. Dubai officials seized on the news to try to repair damage done by weeks of uncertainty stemming from their unwillingness to fully stand behind Dubai World as the conglomerate looked to restructure some of its $60 billion in debts.
Investors cheered Monday’s news. Dubai’s main index shot up 10.4 percent at the close and markets elsewhere rose modestly.
Prior to the crisis, most investors had assumed the Dubai government itself, possibly with Abu Dhabi’s help, would guarantee debts amassed by its chief growth engine.
Dubai authorities are scrambling to reshape the business hub’s battered image, vowing that the city-state is committed to “transparency, good governance and market principles.” Officials outlined a new legal framework that promised to increase openness and protect creditors in future dealings with the conglomerate, offering lenders succor in a country where formal bankruptcy proceedings are largely untested.
“We are here today to reassure investors, financial and trade creditors, employees and our citizens that our government will act at all times in accordance with market principles and internationally accepted business practices,” Sheik Ahmed bin Saeed Al Maktoum, chairman of the Dubai supreme fiscal committee, said in a statement.
Some $4.1 billion of the funds released Monday will go toward meeting a deadline to repay Islamic bonds issued by Dubai World’s Nakheel property arm. The conglomerate, whose sprawling holdings range from the oceanliner Queen Elizabeth 2 to luxury retailer Barney’s New York, will use the rest.
The move, however, carries broader implications as UAE officials have looked to assure the market the country’s economy was on solid ground. Their assurances gave voice to a silent concern that the whole country would be hit by the same investor mistrust that Dubai now faces.
The bailout bought Dubai, itself saddled with more than $80 billion in debts including Dubai World’s, time it desperately needs.
“This is a very significant development,” said Marios Maratheftis, head of regional research at Standard Chartered Bank. “It shows once again there is a one-country approach in dealing with the crisis, which is positive.”
But it was unclear if the news — assurances and funding alike — would prove to be more than a temporary salve.
Standard & Poor’s, which along with other credit rating agencies has aggressively cut its outlook on Dubai state-run companies, called Monday’s move “a step towards rebuilding confidence.” But it warned that the government’s ability to bail out other firms remains uncertain.
Fitch Ratings, another credit agency, also urged caution, saying Abu Dhabi’s bailout was “tactical in nature as opposed to a reversal of recent rhetoric regarding state support.”
Abu Dhabi, which controls the UAE’s presidency, has directly and indirectly provided Dubai with $25 billion over the past year, mostly by buying Dubai bonds. In all, Dubai’s known debts are roughly equal to its total economic output last year. The full extent of its liabilities is uncertain, however, with some analysts putting the total at $100 billion or more.
The aid package is key for Dubai, which despite its international celebrity has little of the oil wealth held by Abu Dhabi. Dubai’s ruler is the UAE’s vice president and prime minister.
Dubai created Dubai World — which has interests in seaports, real estate, tourism and retail — to diversify its economy and boost its international clout. Much of the growth was fueled by easy credit. As the bills came due, the emirate struggled to repay as its economy was battered by the global economic downturn.
Nakheel, a property developer and hotel operator best known for building manmade islands in the shape of palm trees and a map of the world off Dubai’s coast, was among those Dubai World companies that relied heavily on that easy money.
Plenty of questions remain, especially as Dubai works to salvage its reputation and the conglomerate tries to deal with the rest of its debts.
Dubai World, while welcoming the financial support, said it was nonetheless pushing ahead with talks to convince lenders to agree to a “standstill” — effectively a delay — on repaying part of its debt.
“This announcement constitutes a specific bailout of Nakheel, suggesting that as an entity (it) was deemed to be ‘too big to fail,’” said Fahd Iqbal, a Dubai-based analyst at Middle East investment bank EFG-Hermes. “It does not, however, constitute a bailout of Dubai Inc. or Dubai World as a whole and this is important to highlight.”
Officials introduced a reorganization law that could be used in case Dubai World is “unable to achieve an acceptable restructuring of its remaining obligations.”
A person close to the Dubai government said the new law provided a legal framework for addressing corporate debt, though it did not mean a bankruptcy filing by state-owned companies was certain.
“The current bankruptcy law is untested,” the person said, insisting on anonymity as a condition for briefing reporters on a conference call. “Dubai World needed a legal process to go through. The government was very focused on creating something that would be fair and transparent to everybody.”
It was not immediately clear what, if anything, Abu Dhabi would expect in exchange for Monday’s funding. Analysts had said an Abu Dhabi bailout could result in it exerting greater influence on its high profile neighbor going forward.
But the individual close to the Dubai government said the money came with no strings attached.
“Let me be clear: Dubai has not given anything up. There have been no conditions on the funding,” he said.
Tags: Abu Dhabi, Bankruptcy Figures, Dubai, Financing, Middle East, Restructuring And Recapitalization, United Arab Emirates